Bottom line for Calloway County insurance shoppers: Calloway County stretches from Murray city limits south to the Tennessee state line, east to Kentucky Lake, and west toward Graves County. Rating varies materially by whether you’re inside Murray, in a Murray-adjacent subdivision, at Kentucky Lake, or on a rural county road — and by fire service distance.
Boswell Insurance Agency is headquartered in Murray, Kentucky and writes home, auto, umbrella, life, and small business insurance across all of Calloway County. Blake Boswell, Erie Insurance appointed agent, 136+ five-star Google reviews.
Calloway County ZIP-level considerations
- 42071 (Murray). City limits, Murray Fire Department PPC. Standard home and auto rating.
- 42054 (Dexter). Rural; fire service distance matters.
- 42049 (New Concord). Kentucky Lake proximity — waterfront rating patterns apply to shoreline properties.
- 42055 (Farmington). Rural western Calloway County.
Related guides
- Insurance agent in Murray, KY: complete guide
- Kentucky Lake home insurance
- Cheap home insurance in Murray, KY
- Car insurance in Murray, KY
Get a Calloway County insurance quote
Call (270) 925-1524 or email BLAKE@theboswellagency.com. Boswell Insurance Agency is at 1051 N 16th Street Suite D, Murray, Kentucky 42071.
