Boswell Insurance Agency is an independent, multi-carrier insurance agency serving Mayfield, Kentucky and all of Graves County from our office at 1051 N 16th St Ste D in Murray — about 25 minutes east on Highway 121. Owner Blake Boswell is a licensed Kentucky insurance agent who built this agency on one rule: service over sales. We quote Erie, Progressive, GEICO, and many more companies, which means you get the right policy for your home and your family — not just the first quote that walks in the door. Whether you live downtown near the Graves County courthouse, out toward Lone Oak Road, or in the neighborhoods that have been rebuilt since the December 2021 tornado, we’d be honored to compete for your business.
Insurance Coverage We Write for Mayfield Residents
We’re a full-service independent agency. The policies we write most often for Mayfield, KY families and businesses include:
Auto Insurance. Coverage for your daily driver, second vehicle, motorcycle, RV, boat, or classic car. We quote Erie, Progressive, GEICO, and many more companies to match your driving history, vehicle, and household. If you commute to Paducah or Murray for work, drive a teen driver to Mayfield High School, or pick up rideshare or delivery work on the side, we have a carrier for you.
Home Insurance. Standard homeowners (HO-3), older home coverage (HO-8), condo (HO-6), rental property (DP-3), and renters policies. Mayfield’s housing stock runs the full range — historic homes near the courthouse square, mid-century neighborhoods, newer subdivisions, and a growing number of fully rebuilt homes from the 2021 storm — and each one fits a different carrier. We’ll show you who’s the right match for your specific home.
Tornado & Storm-Exposed Property. West Kentucky’s storm risk is real, and Mayfield knows that better than most. Replacement-cost coverage, debris-removal limits, ordinance-or-law coverage, and loss-of-use limits are the line items that actually matter when a claim happens. We walk you through them in plain English before you sign — not after a storm.
Life Insurance. Term and whole life from top-rated carriers. The best time to lock in life insurance is when you’re young and healthy — we’ll walk you through the options without pressure.
Small Business / Commercial. General liability, BOP, workers’ comp, commercial auto, and cyber for Mayfield contractors, retailers, restaurants, salons, and professional offices. The Graves County rebuild has brought a wave of new small businesses to Mayfield — we’d be glad to be your insurance partner.
Why Choose an Independent Agent in Mayfield Over a Captive Agency?
Captive agents — the ones who work for a single company like State Farm, Allstate, or Farm Bureau — can only sell you that one company’s policies. If their rates go up, they can’t move you anywhere else without you firing them. As an independent agency serving Mayfield, KY, we represent 12+ carriers, which means:
- When one carrier raises rates, we shop the others — your loyalty stays with us, not with whoever happens to be cheapest this year.
- We can match the carrier to your specific situation. Erie is excellent for clean-driving Graves County families bundling home and auto. Progressive often fits prior-incident drivers better. GEICO can be a strong fit for younger drivers and certain auto profiles. Each client gets the right home, not the only home.
- Claims help comes from a person you know. If you have a claim, you call our office and Blake or Katie walks you through it. You’re not dialing a 1-800 number and explaining your situation to a stranger every time.
- We’re here for the long haul. Boswell Insurance Agency is locally owned, operated, and accountable. We see clients at the grocery store, at church, and at the kids’ ball games — that’s the kind of accountability that doesn’t exist with a faceless call center.
Serving All of Mayfield and Graves County
We write insurance across all of Mayfield and the surrounding Graves County area, including:
- Downtown Mayfield and the courthouse square
- The US-45 / Paducah Road corridor north of town
- Lone Oak Road and the neighborhoods toward Symsonia
- The KY-80 corridor east toward Murray
- South Mayfield and the Highway 45 South corridor
- Rebuilt neighborhoods along Cuba Road, Backusburg Road, and Old Dublin Road
- Wingo, Water Valley, and Pilot Oak
- Fancy Farm, Lowes, and Folsomdale
- Sedalia, Farmington, and Coldwater
If you live or own property anywhere in Graves, Calloway, Marshall, McCracken, Hickman, or Carlisle County, we can write you.
How to Get a Quote from Boswell Insurance Agency
You have three ways to start:
- Call us: (270) 925-1524 — Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Central. We answer.
- Online quote request: Secure Quote Request — takes 3 minutes; we’ll get back to you within one business day.
- Stop by: 1051 N 16th St Ste D, Murray, KY 42071. Walk-ins welcome. (We’re about 25 minutes from Mayfield via KY-121.)
Bring your current declarations page if you have one — that lets us match coverage apples-to-apples and tell you straight whether we can beat what you have or whether you’re already in the right place.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you write insurance in Mayfield, KY even though your office is in Murray?
Yes — Mayfield and all of Graves County are part of our regular service area. We write policies statewide in Kentucky, and Mayfield is one of our most-served communities outside Calloway County. We handle everything by phone, email, and online; in-person visits are welcome at the Murray office.
Do you write farm or ranch insurance?
Not at this time. We focus on personal auto, home, life, and small business insurance. If you need a farm policy, we’d be happy to point you toward a Western Kentucky farm specialist.
Can you help me rebuild or re-insure a home that was damaged in the 2021 tornado?
Yes. Many Mayfield homeowners are still re-insuring rebuilt homes, finishing claims, or moving carriers after the storm. We help you compare carriers, review replacement-cost numbers, and make sure your new policy actually reflects what it would cost to rebuild today.
Who is Blake Boswell?
Blake Boswell is the owner and a licensed Kentucky insurance agent. He founded Boswell Insurance Agency to offer Western Kentucky a faith-rooted, locally accountable alternative to captive and call-center agencies.
Is Boswell Insurance Agency a captive agent for one company?
No — Boswell Insurance Agency is an independent, multi-carrier insurance agency. We quote Erie, Progressive, GEICO, and many more companies, so we can shop the right fit for each client rather than being limited to one company’s policies.
Do you offer Erie Insurance in Mayfield, KY?
Yes — Boswell Insurance Agency is an appointed Erie Insurance agency. Erie is one of our most-used carriers for auto, home, life, and business policies across Western Kentucky, including Graves County.
How much does insurance cost in Mayfield, KY?
Premiums vary widely based on your home’s age, your driving history, the carrier, and dozens of other factors — there is no universal “Mayfield rate.” That’s exactly why we shop multiple carriers. Send us your current declarations page and we’ll give you a straight answer on whether we can save you money or whether you’re already priced right.
Can I get a quote without obligation?
Yes. There’s no fee, no obligation, and no high-pressure follow-up if our quote isn’t a fit. We’d rather you walk away knowing what your real options are than feel pushed into a sale.
What are your office hours?
Monday through Friday, 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM Central. We respond to quote requests and messages outside hours on the next business day.
Other Western Kentucky Service Areas
Looking for insurance in a nearby Western Kentucky community? We serve clients across the region from our Murray office:
