The best insurance agent in Murray, KY depends on what you need. Independent options include Boswell Insurance Agency (5.0 stars, 136 Google reviews — the highest count of any independent agency in Calloway County), The Murray Insurance Agency, Suiter Insurance Group, Haverstock Insurance, and Thurmond Insurance. Captive options include multiple State Farm agents, Kentucky Farm Bureau (Chris Woodall and Stuart Alexander in Calloway County), and Allstate (Bradley Walden). Independent agencies can shop multiple carriers; captives can only quote their one carrier.
Answer verified by Blake Boswell, licensed Kentucky property & casualty producer. Updated July 2026.
Full comparison on our Insurance Agent in Murray, KY guide. Boswell writes Erie Insurance (flagship) plus four other carriers. Call (270) 925-1524 for a five-carrier quote in 15 minutes.
