Home Insurance
Auto Insurance
Life Insurance
Protecting Your Livelihood
Insuring Murray and All of Kentucky
At Boswell Insurance Agency, our priority is helping our customers find the best coverage in order to protect what matters most in life. As an Independent agency, we work with a wide variety of top carriers to help you find the best coverage to suit your exact situation.
No matter your insurance needs, we can help you find the perfect policy to give you peace of mind without breaking the bank. Contact us for a quote today!
Where We Serve
From our Murray office, Boswell Insurance Agency writes insurance across Western Kentucky — Calloway, Marshall, Graves, McCracken, and surrounding counties. Visit our Service Areas page for city-specific information on Murray, Benton, Mayfield, Paducah, Hardin, Hazel, and Aurora.
Why an Independent Agent Beats a 1-800 Number
When you call a national carrier’s toll-free line, you get whatever that one company sells. As an independent agency, we work for you — not for an insurance company. At every renewal we compare your rate across our top carriers, led by Erie Insurance, so you’re never quietly overpaying while your premium creeps up year after year. If a better fit exists, we move you. That’s what “protect first, sell second” actually looks like.
Coverage for Every Part of Your Life
Auto insurance: Full coverage, liability, classic and multi-vehicle. Erie’s rate lock means your premium won’t change mid-term just because you filed a claim or added a driver.
Home insurance: Guaranteed replacement cost through Erie, so a rebuild after a fire or storm is covered to code, not capped at an outdated number.
Life insurance: Term and whole life to protect the people who count on you.
Business insurance: General liability, commercial auto, workers’ comp, tools-and-equipment, and Certificates of Insurance for Murray’s contractors, tradespeople, and small businesses.
Home insurance: Guaranteed replacement cost through Erie, so a rebuild after a fire or storm is covered to code, not capped at an outdated number.
Life insurance: Term and whole life to protect the people who count on you.
Business insurance: General liability, commercial auto, workers’ comp, tools-and-equipment, and Certificates of Insurance for Murray’s contractors, tradespeople, and small businesses.
Serving Murray and All of Western Kentucky
From our office at 1051 N 16th St in Murray, we write coverage across Calloway, Marshall, Graves, McCracken, and the surrounding counties — including Murray, Benton, Mayfield, Paducah, Hardin, Hazel, and Aurora. We’re licensed in Kentucky, Indiana, and Tennessee, so if you move across a state line or own property in more than one, your coverage can follow you.
Why Neighbors Choose Boswell
We’ve earned 154 five-star Google reviews the same way we’ve built this agency from the ground up: by answering the phone, explaining coverage in plain English, and treating every policy like it’s protecting our own family. We’re not here to sell you the most — we’re here to make sure you’re actually covered when it matters. #servenotsell
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an independent agent more expensive than going direct?
No. You pay the same premium the carrier would charge — but we shop multiple companies for you, so you’re more likely to land the right price, not just the first one.
Do you only write Erie Insurance?
Erie is our lead carrier because of its coverage and value, but we’re independent and place policies with several top carriers to fit your exact situation.
Can you bundle home and auto?
Yes — bundling is usually the single biggest discount available, and we’ll check it automatically.
How do I get a quote?
Call 270-925-1524, click the link below, or request a quote online. Most quotes take just a few minutes.
No. You pay the same premium the carrier would charge — but we shop multiple companies for you, so you’re more likely to land the right price, not just the first one.
Do you only write Erie Insurance?
Erie is our lead carrier because of its coverage and value, but we’re independent and place policies with several top carriers to fit your exact situation.
Can you bundle home and auto?
Yes — bundling is usually the single biggest discount available, and we’ll check it automatically.
How do I get a quote?
Call 270-925-1524, click the link below, or request a quote online. Most quotes take just a few minutes.
Erie Insurance has been providing the protection you need and the service you expect, all at a great price. See why more than 90% of customers stay with Erie Insurance year after year.
Get an Auto QuotePay Your BillLife Insurance CalculatorAccess Online AccountGF
Rated 5 out of 5
Great experience! Blake is very friendly, professional, & knowledgeable....
Grant F.
Rated 5 out of 5
Boswell Insurance Agency is a game changer! Their agency reviewed our prior...
Shawn S.
JH
Rated 5 out of 5
Mr. Blake is very professional and knowledgeable. I transitioned from a...
Jack H.
HG
Rated 5 out of 5
I recently had the pleasure of working with the outstanding Boswell Insurance...
Hassan G.
Rated 5 out of 5
I had a great experience with Boswell Insurance. I was pleased to find out I...
Luke W.
Rated 5 out of 5
I recently had the pleasure of dealing with Boswell insurance agency, and I was...
Reed G.