Skip to main content

Independent Insurance · Murray, Kentucky

Insurance that actually covers you when it matters.

We take the time to understand what you're protecting, shop 6 carriers on your behalf, and explain your options in plain English — no runaround.

155+ five-star Google reviews · Licensed in KY, IN & TN

155+
Five-Star Reviews
5.0
Google Rating
3
States Licensed
6
Carriers We Shop

You Call, We Answer

No phone trees, no call centers, no "please hold." You get a real person from a local office who knows your account.

We Shop, You Choose

We quote across 6 carriers — led by Erie Insurance — instead of handing you whatever one company happens to offer.

Re-Shopped Every Renewal

We compare your rate across our carriers at every renewal — so you're never quietly overpaying while your premium creeps up.

Why Work With an Independent Agency

What Makes Boswell Insurance Agency Different

When you call a national carrier's toll-free line, you get whatever that one company sells. As an independent agency, we work for you — not for an insurance company. At every renewal we compare your rate across our top carriers, led by Erie Insurance, so you're never quietly overpaying while your premium creeps up year after year. If a better fit exists, we move you. That's what 'protect first, sell second' actually looks like.

Our Story

We Don't Just Write Policies and Disappear

We stick around for the renewals, the claims, the "I just bought a boat" phone calls, and the "what does this letter mean?" moments. That's the whole point of working with a local, independent agency.

Real Situations, Real Outcomes

How We've Helped Our Clients

Auto Insurance

Better auto coverage for less

The situation:Reed G. (Murray, KY) was shopping his auto policy.

The result:I recently had the pleasure of dealing with Boswell Insurance Agency and I was blown away. Blake found me better auto coverage for less than I was paying and actually explained what each limit meant instead of just quoting a number.

Home Insurance

Caught an underinsured home

The situation:Grant F.'s old homeowners policy was insuring his house for far less than rebuild cost.

The result:Great experience! Blake is very friendly, professional and knowledgeable. He caught that my old homeowners policy was insuring my house for far less than it would cost to rebuild it.

Business Insurance

Commercial gaps found and fixed

The situation:Shawn S. (Benton, KY) had a commercial policy no one had reviewed.

The result:Boswell Insurance Agency is a game changer. Their agency reviewed our prior commercial policy, found gaps our old agent never mentioned, and got us better protection at a comparable price.

6+ Trusted Carriers

We Shop the Market For You

As an independent agency, we aren't tied to one company. We compare coverage and pricing across the carriers below to find the fit that's right for you.

Plus access to

American ModernSteadily (landlord & rental)

What Our Clients Say

5.0

Based on 173 Google reviews

T

Tyler Colyer

2 months ago

Blake and his team were great getting our home and auto policy set up at a competitive rate. We moved to Murray recently and he came highly recommended by our realtor and several members of the community. The process was super quick and easy and it was great to talk to someone local and have access to my agent versus having to contact someone at a call center. It was also refreshing to call the office and have his team remember me by name and what we had going on in terms of our business. Highly recommend if you are shopping for insurance!!

J

Justin Lange

4 months ago

I had a great experience working with Boswell Insurance. I originally worked with them on a commercial policy for my business, but it was clear pretty quickly that they handle everything—from business insurance to personal coverage—and do it the right way. As a business owner, having the right coverage is critical, and they made the entire process simple and stress-free. They took the time to really understand my business, walk through my risks, and explain my options in a way that actually made sense. I never felt like I was being sold something I didn't need—they were focused on protecting me, not just closing a deal. What stood out the most was their responsiveness and attention to detail. Any time I had a question, they were quick to respond and made sure everything was handled correctly from start to finish. If you're in Murray, Paducah, or anywhere in Western Kentucky and need help with business insurance, home, auto, or anything in between, I highly recommend Boswell Insurance. It's hard to find people who are both knowledgeable and genuinely care, but they definitely deliver.

R

Rachel Throneburg

a month ago

Blake and Katie made getting renters insurance quick, easy, and completely stress-free. They were kind, knowledgeable, and took the time to answer all of my questions without ever making me feel rushed. I loved working with them!

M

Michael Lawrence

4 months ago

I didn't realize how undercovered I was until Boswell Insurance walked me through everything. They took the time to explain what I had, what I was missing, and why it mattered. No pressure — just honest, helpful guidance. They got everything adjusted to fit my situation, and I feel a lot more confident now. If you haven't reviewed your insurance in a while, I'd recommend talking to them.

L

Lexus Gooch

6 months ago

Best insurance agency I have went through, fast, reliable, and always helps when needed. Had an accident of someone else’s fault. They were able to reach out to the other insurance and I got a call back for a rental and estimate within less then 24 hours. The agency and agents that help are wonderful.

N

Noah Gray

2 months ago

Boswell Insurance was very quick and efficient. Blake and the others were very friendly and made sure I was well taken care of. Got a good deal on car insurance and great service!

Proudly Serving Our Communities

Calloway County, KY: Murray (home base) and Hazel • Marshall County, KY: Benton, Hardin, Aurora — Kentucky Lake & Land Between the Lakes • Graves County, KY: Mayfield • McCracken County, KY: Paducah, Reidland, Lone Oak • Henry County, TN: Paris, Puryear • Plus Trigg, Hickman, Carlisle, Ballard, Livingston, and surrounding Western Kentucky counties

Ready for Coverage That Actually Fits?

Tell us what you're protecting and we'll shop the market, review the fine print, and walk you through your options — no obligation.